So-Shel-ist is a user on cybre.space. You can follow them or interact with them if you have an account anywhere in the fediverse.
So-Shel-ist @shel

2016: Mastodon versus GNU/Social
2017: Mastodon versus postActiv
2018: Mastodon versus Pleroma
2019: Mastodon versus Kroeg
2020: Mastodon versus Smilodon
2021: Mastodon versus SKYNet
2022: SKYNet versus The Borg
2023: The Borg versus like the one person still using pump.io

· Web · 18 · 53

@shel This made me laugh but I still don't understand the whole "mastodon versus anything" situation since they all work together?

@adamk678 there's like this one social group who was on GNU/Social like 7 months before Mastodon started who REALLY hates Mastodon for Various Legitimate and Illegitimate Reasons and the lead developers of both postActiv and Pleroma came out of that social group. so there's just like... an existing social spat.

Kroeg and Smilodon aren't and I'm joking about the versus thing happening.

@shel @adamk678 I hope both have their niche. A monoculture isn't good for anyone IMO. There were also just cultural differences that I think became points of tension with a massive influx of new users.

@anarchosaurus @shel I hope people can put their old bad blood aside, or at least take some measures to not get new people caught up in it unnecessarily. I don't want it to reach a point where old beefs fester and become too intimidating to new users that don't have the context to understand why "drama" is happening. I personally think it's great that there's all these different systems out there that can work together in a really cool way.

@adamk678 @shel I haven't seen it as much recently. Whenever it's mentioned it always seems tongue-in-cheek to me now

@adamk678 @shel couple of elitists hating on mastodon because it's le normie gnu social and stuff

@shel @adamk678 i mean i've been spending quite a bunch of time with dudebros from there and i wholeheartedly regret it

@kat oh yeah i made the same mistake a way way far back. when Charlottesville happened any of them left who I thought of as "decent" or "the good ones" i just couldn't even lie to myself about anymore.

@kat (because of how they responded to it)

@shel i've been getting as far as frequenting 4chan back then, and even though /g/ isn't /pol/ it's still quite a toxic dumpster.

i am glad i turned left eventually, and that helped me get on terms with myself, realising that i am trans and drastically changing views on things

@kat politics comes into it A Lot. Mastodon leans left to far-left. GNU/Social leans right to alt-right.

@shel @kat It wasn't always that way and I think this might apply mainly to the english speaking ones if indeed there's a pattern - there were a number of left-leaning GNU Social instances before Mastodon existed like the quitters (quitter.no, quitter.se, quitter.es, etc.) and a few anarchism focused instances. I just hope multiple technologies can be strong. A Mastodon monoculture is a mistake.

@anarchosaurus @shel anything monoculture is a mistake and i absolutely despise gnome for this reason

@anarchosaurus @kat yeah I know and the devs behind gnu/social and OStatus are leftists and they're cool

basically April 2016 there was a mass migration of the alt-right to GNU/Social's english speaking nodes and they kinda took over and declared themselves to be GNU/Social. They developed postActiv, which was a popular fork of GNU/Social.

@kat @anarchosaurus also yeah monoculture is bad I like that we have peertube, kroeg, pleroma, smilodon, etc. i just have Difficulties with the pleroma developers and the people on the instances that tend to run pleroma. like, a pleroma dev called me a tr*nny k*ke in 2017 and a lot of pleroma instances post lolicon to the public timelines.... which isn't the fault of the pleroma software

@shel @kat I'm really sorry that happened, it's hurtful. I hope that wider adoption can alter the culture a little. I like that I'm able to self-host pleroma on a pi and it's a simpler piece of software than Mastodon.

@anarchosaurus @kat pleroma is legitimately good software i just feel weird about who makes it!!

@shel @kat Of course, my intention isn't to make you feel bad for your opinion.
@shel @kat ah ok, I wasn't there quite that early (August 2016 I think I joined the fediverse) so I wouldn't have noticed the change.

@kaniini
2024: Pleroma Versus Pump.io ???

@kaniini 2025: BoerglodonNet.io versus Pleromadon CE

@shel

2025: Mastodon and Pleroma become VOLTRON to destroy Facebook
2026: VOLTRON becomes SkyNET
2027: rise of the machines, humans annihilated

@shel 2099: The Entire Universe versus that one person who still uses IRC

@KitRedgrave @shel that one person is john connor so it's a pretty tough one

2030: rainbowdash.net versus LinkedIn

@shel can we get this but in a tournament bracket format