Watching "Arrival" finally, read the story a long time ago (and Chiang uses a lot of bullshit rhetorical tricks/fake reveals in his stories, so not my favorite).
The very 1990s looking setting and use of TV & tape recorders instead of phones is weird. I can't tell what's anachronism and what's incompetence.

"The cornerstone of civilization is language." "The cornerstone of civilization is science."

No, the cornerstone of civilization is beer and bread. We only made cities so we could harvest grain for these things.

So they see some tentacle aliens and just freak out? They shoulda sent an anime fangirl, not a poet.

Arrival spoiler 

The word for "everyone gets some by cooperating" is "reciprocity", not "non-zero-sum game". The latter still has winners and losers.

Arrival spoiler 

The trite Ted Chiang ending is 10x worse thru a Hollywood vaseline love scene filter.
And the giant knuckle tentacle aliens will be back in Arrival 2 vs Predator vs The Fog vs Gandalf: Smoke Ring Blowoff!

True. But beer and bread is science, arguably. 🤖

@Wintermute Secondary development. Trade in grain eventually created measurement which created math & science (literally "cutting apart", like division of profits).

...But fermentation and distillation is basic chemistry. I'm not necessarily disagreeing, just saying one followed the other is short succession.

Sign in to participate in the conversation

cybrespace: the social hub of the information superhighway jack in to the mastodon fediverse today and surf the dataflow through our cybrepunk, slightly glitchy web portal support us on patreon or liberapay!